13
May
Thinking Cup - Boston, MA
For years, Starbucks been promoting the concept that a company can run a “great coffee shop” without serving good food. Kenny informed me that a new coffee shop opened on Tremont street by the Common called Thinking Cup Coffee Shop. When I first arrived at Thinking Cup, I thought “Thievery Corporation at 9:30 AM? I can get into that.” I am a big fan of Thievery Corporation, but almost every restaurant that plays their music just smacks of pretense (and not in a way that I like).
The coffee at Thinking Cup is pretty good, in fact I would argue it is some of the best in Boston. However, all of their staff has this obnoxious hipster attitude. Not Jamaica Plain hipsters (we get along), but more like Portland hipster (the pinnacle of hipsterdom). I recently became enamoured of the pourover style of coffee (where they pour hot water over coffee). For some reason, this coffee has far more complex flavors than regular coffee. So, I decided to order a cup of coffee, and the “barista” asked “What flavor do you want?” and then pointed to a 8” x 12” sign 20 feet away. I wasn’t about to walk all the way over to the far end of the bar just to read what 3 flavors of coffee existed, so I just asked him to tell me. The service is a little too into themselves to actually take your order, but when you get your coffee, it’s worth it. I should also point out that the coffee is surprisingly small for what you’re paying for. The smallest size is 8 oz, so paying over 3 bucks for an 8 oz coffee is a little steep.

Oh, I forgot to mention that this is a food blog (but you already knew that, right?). I ordered the egg and cheese on an English muffin sandwich, which was pretty good, though I would argue a little steep for four dollars. The annoying part of their breakfast sandwiches is that meat is built into the price. So, if you just want an egg and cheese, you have to pay as if you wanted a sausage/bacon/ham with eggs and cheese.

While I have already sort of made up my opinion of Thinking Cup, I thought I would at least try out their grilled cheese sandwich to give them a fair review. The grilled cheese is the only vegetarian sandwich on their meager sandwich menu. I have always said that good bread is the greatest barometer of how good a sandwich is going to be. Unfortunately for this grilled cheese, the bread was so much better than the cheese. If you’re going to use really nice bread for your grilled cheese, you can go better than Kraft slices. The grilled cheese was very cheesy, but it was unsatisfyingly so.
The food at Thinking Cup is just as awful as you’d expect to find in Starbucks. I would argue that the coffee is considerably better. However, the attitude is much worse (yes, it is possible to be snootier than a Starbucks barista!), and the prices are much higher. For these reasons, I don’t think I can give Thinking Cup more than two cheese sandwiches.


Thinking Cup
165 Tremont Street
Boston, MA 02111
(617) 482-5555

















